Wildfire Insurance Crisis Hits Ever Harder

By Thomas Elias

Californians have heard plenty about the wildfire crisis that’s afflicted this state for the last few years, highlighted by a rash of huge blazes and evacuations of more than 1 million area residents.

But as the height of the annual fire season approaches, there has been little attention paid to the ever-increasing expenses inflicted on property owners and renters in or near wildlands, who may not ever be burned out, but are certainly getting burned.

For a fire insurance crisis of ever increasing magnitude is now upon California and the state has done nothing to prevent or mitigate it.

While thousands of owners and occupants of properties fully or partially destroyed in fires from Redding to Paradise to Napa to Ventura and Malibu still wrestle with lawyers and insurance companies as they try for damage compensation, other thousands are getting hit now via their mailboxes.

Increasing numbers of potential fire area residents from the Sierra Nevada Mountain foothills to plush residential areas in suburban San Diego County and the hills of the East Bay are receiving cancellation notices from their property insurance firms, forcing them to seek new policies just when most insurers want to rid themselves of potential liabilities in or near California’s forests and brushlands.

Others are seeing their policy premiums doubled and tripled.

One typical homeowner in Oakhurst near the southern approach road to Yosemite National Park saw his rate raised this spring from just over $2,000 a year to more than $6,000. But at least he can still buy insurance on the general market.

Thousands more are being forced onto the open market, trying to obtain coverage from reluctant insurers.

It’s a situation reminiscent of the mid-1990s, when every large insurance company in America boycotted the California homeowners insurance market. They cancelled or declined to renew virtually every homeowners insurance policy in the state after the 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake and 1994’s Northridge temblor combined to inflict billions of dollars of expenses on them.

Rather than insisting that insurance companies continue to offer quake insurance or be banned from selling other lucrative coverage – like car and truck policies – in California, then-Insurance Commissioner Chuck Quackenbush allowed the boycott to continue and proposed creation of a state-run system that evolved into the California Earthquake Authority (CEA). Insurance companies resumed selling homeowner policies, but are off the hook now in California quakes, and would love the same to apply in wildfires.
But so far, state lawmakers – like their predecessors who were cowed during the 1990s – refuse to do much of anything. Among the biggest unresolved issues that legislators won’t directly confront this year is whether to limit liability of insurance companies with burned-out customers.

All of which means that what former Gov. Jerry Brown said last year about wildfires and climate change – “All hell is breaking loose” – applies now to more than actual fires.

Former Insurance Commissioner Dave Jones foresaw some of this two years ago, observing that insurers must renew policies for a time in actual fire disaster areas, but they don’t have to renew policies in non-disaster areas when they expire.

That’s the root of the current crisis. The insurance companies understand many so-far-unburned parts of California will inevitably become disaster areas and don’t want their own finances impacted when those disasters hit.

There is a safety net of sorts for homeowners when their policies aren’t renewed. It’s called the Fair Plan, roughly equivalent to the CEA in that it must insure anyone who applies. But Fair Plan rates are much higher than other fire policies, even at their increased rates. Yes, by law they cannot be excessive, but no one is sure what that means.

Before last year’s fires, the number of Fair Plan policies was rising by about 1,000 per year. That will likely climb substantially over the coming months and years, eventually making the fire insurance crisis less about scarce policies than it is about money.

The bottom line: Even if their houses don’t ignite in any of the next few fire seasons, plenty of homeowners will see their wallets get seriously burned, with state government unable or unwilling to protect them.

Related Posts

‘A Lie of the Mind’ Will be PaliHi Fall Play

October 25, 2016

October 25, 2016

Sam Shepard’s A Lie of the Mind will be the Palisades High School fall drama and will play at 7...

‘Allergist’s Wife’ at Theatre Palisades Opens Friday

October 27, 2016

October 27, 2016

The final offering of the 2016 Theatre Palisades season is The Tale of the Allergist’s Wife, an offbeat comedy by...

$5K Donation by Anthony Marguleas Benefits the Palisades Village Green

January 24, 2017

January 24, 2017 1

By Sue Pascoe Editor The Village Green, the treasured pocket-park at Sunset, Swarthmore and Antioch, requires an annual budget of...

#1 Ranked Jason Day Will Play Genesis Open

February 16, 2017

February 16, 2017

by Sue Pascoe Editor Jason Day, the 29-year-old Australian golfer, who is ranked No. 1 in the world, will seek...

‘Beauty and the Beast, Jr.’ Will Open July 28 at Pierson Playhouse

July 23, 2017

July 23, 2017

Be Our Guest” is not only a memorable song from Disney’s “Beauty and Beast, Jr.”, but also the invitation extended...

$400K Pledged to Park Garden at Palisades Recreation Center

August 16, 2017

August 16, 2017

By Sue Pascoe  Editor American Legion Post 283 has pledged $400,000 towards a project to renovate the picnic area and...

‘Anything Is Possible’ Book Discussion Scheduled at Palisades Branch Library

September 15, 2017

September 15, 2017

The Palisades Branch Library book club will discuss Elizabeth Strout’s latest book “Anything Is Possible” from noon to 1:30 p.m....

‘Curb Your Enthusiasm’ Returns to Pacific Palisades

October 8, 2017

October 8, 2017

Story and photos by Bernice Fox Special to the Palisades News Just like the show’s fans, Larry David missed “Curb...

‘Aladdin’ at Hollywood Pantages Theatre Provides Family Fun

January 15, 2018

January 15, 2018

By Laurel Busby Staff Writer Like a Disney amusement park ride, “Aladdin” at the Pantages is full of dizzying colorful...

‘Freud’s Last Session’ at the Odyssey Theatre Is Cogent, Witty

February 15, 2018

February 15, 2018

By Libby Motika Palisades News Contributor One wonders if the avowed atheist Sigmund Freud, reckoning with the painful fatal stages...

‘Aladdin’ Dazzles Families at Hollywood Pantages

March 1, 2018

March 1, 2018

By Laurel Busby Staff Writer Like a Disney amusement park ride, “Aladdin” at the Pantages is full of dizzying colorful...

‘Happiest Song’ at LA Theatre Center Delivers a Warm, Vibrant Finale

March 3, 2018

March 3, 2018

  By Laurel Busby Staff Writer At its core, “The Happiest Song Plays Last” is a tale of the often...

‘Footloose’ Opens at PaliHi

April 4, 2018

April 4, 2018

“Footloose” will open tomorrow, April 5 at 7 p.m. in Mercer Hall at Palisades High School, 15777 Bowdoin St. The...

‘Amazon of Transportation’: Uber’s Secret Talks to Buy Bird or Lime

December 10, 2018

December 10, 2018

Ride-hailing giant looks to acquire Bird or Lime before going public. By Sam Catanzaro A little over a year after...

$9 Million Fraud Case in Palisades

January 2, 2019

January 2, 2019

Jury orders Pacific Palisades Bowl Mobile Estates to pay two residents. By Staff Writer Two former residents of a Palisades...

Comments
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *